Radio Programs - Now Playing
Crosstalk

Listen to Archives, Read/Leave Feedback
Today's Schedule, Radio Show List
David Barton Takes on Those Who Say It is Unbiblical For Sarah Palin to be Vice-President
by Brannon Howse
Upcoming Conferences
October 12, 2008
St. Paul, MN:

October 25, 2008
Lansing, Michigan

October 26, 2008
Columbus, Ohio

November 14th
Quad Cities (Moline, IL)

November 15, 2008
Des Moines, Iowa:

November 16, 2008
Rockford, IL

November 22, 2008
Wichita, Kansas

November 23, 2008
Kansas City, Kansas

April 24, 25 & 26, 2009
Branson, Missouri

Meet Brannon Howse
President & Founder, View Bio

Brannon Howse

Schedule Brannon
for your next event
Search
Search:

View articles by:



















Summit Ministries







Worldview DVDs
Bob Cornuke and David Limbaugh DVD
Only $14.99!

Brannon Howse / Voddie Baucham Jr. DVD
Only $14.99!

Candace Cameron/Brannon Howse DVD
Only $15.00!

David Barton / Carl Kerby DVD
Only $14.99!
David Barton and David Jeremiah DVD
Only $14.99!

David Barton DVD
Only $9.99!
Dr. Marshall Foster / Janet Folger
Only $14.99!
Jason Carlson/Mark Cahill DVD
Only $15.00!

Ken Ham DVD
Only $14.99!

Kerby Anderson / Dr. Marshall Foster
Only $14.99!
Michael Reagan DVD
Only $14.99!

Norm Geisler / Norm Geisler
Only $14.99!
Ravi Zacharias and Brannon Howse DVD
Only $14.99!

Ron Carlson / Brannon Howse
Only $14.99!
Sean McDowell / Josh McDowell DVD
Only $14.99!

Woodrow Kroll / David Jeremiah DVD
Only $14.99!

The Seductive and Subversive "Shack"



Posted: 06/24/2008

The Seductive and Subversive "Shack"

By Jan Markell 
 
Many have asked me to comment on William P. Young's ragingly popular book The Shack.  Is this work of fiction really Christian?  It is called by some as one of Christianity's most influential books.  One prominent endorser says it will "leave you craving for God." 

 

Yet people I respect highly, including Dr. Albert Mohler, President of Southern Baptist Seminary, calls it "undiluted heresy." He maintains there is no way it can seriously address the issues of Christian faith.

 

Here is the scenario in brief. Remember, this fiction plot is going to transform lives!  A man by the name of "Mack" has a daughter murdered and he slips into a depression. He gets a message that he is supposed to meet God in the shack. Entering the shack, he is in the company of the Trinity, but now it gets weird and hard to believe anyone could be deceived by this piece of work.

 

In the shack he learns that God is "Papa" but is really an African-American female. Thankfully, Jesus is a Jewish man, but the Holy Spirit is another female figure of Asian descent. So much for Trinitarian theology!  So Christianity has been misconstrued and has been revised.  Talk about minimizing the Divine!

 

On page 110 Jesus says that He is perhaps not the way, truth, and life, but the BEST way to relate to the Father and Holy Spirit. Papa God, the African-American female, says she has many followers of many religions in different lands. This is not Orthodox Christianity, yet millions of Christian readers claim it is!  Discernment has taken a summer vacation or perhaps a permanent vacation.

 

Mack asks "Papa" God, the female, about God's wrath. The answer is that she doesn't punish people for sin; rather she wants to cure sin.  No mention of repentance, the shed blood, and all the things the new "seeker" environment wants to leave out in the church parking lot.

 

Former "New Ager" Warren Smith says, "The Shack is being described as a Christian novel and is currently ranked number one on the New York Times best-seller list for paperback fiction. Many believers are buying multiple copies and giving them to friends and family. The Shack reads as a true story but is obviously allegorical fiction. The book conveys postmodern spiritual ideas and teachings that challenge biblical Christianity - all in the name of 'God' and 'Jesus' and the 'Holy Spirit.' Author William P. Young's alternative presentation of traditional Christianity has both inspired and outraged his many readers. All the while his book continues to fly off the shelves of local bookstores."

 

Smith, who has been on my radio program many times denouncing Oprah Winfrey's deception, goes on to say, "I was drawn into the 'New Age Movement' years ago by books and lectures containing parabolic stories that were not unlike The Shack. They felt spiritually uplifting as they tackled tough issues and talked about God's love and forgiveness. They seemed to provide me with what I spiritually needed as they gave me much-needed hope and promise. Building on the credibility they achieved through their inspirational and emotive writings, my 'New Age' authors and teachers would then go on to tell me that God was in everyone and everything.

 

"I discovered that author William P. Young does exactly the same thing in The Shack. He moves through his very engaging and emotional story to eventually present this same 'New Age' teaching that God is 'in' everything."

As writer and researcher Berit Kjos concludes, "Yet countless pastors and church leaders are delighting in its message. By ignoring (or redefining) sin and guilt, they embrace an inclusive but counterfeit 'Christianity' that draws crowds but distorts the Bible. Discounting Satan as well, they weaken God's warnings about deception. No wonder His armor for today's spiritual war became an early victim of this spreading assault on truth."

So The Shack opens in the context of tragedy. Four years have passed since the cruel murder of Missy, Mack's precious six-year-old daughter. Enveloped in grief, he receives a strange invitation. "I've missed you," it says. "I'll be at the shack next weekend if you want to get together. Papa." What could it mean?

Doubtful, but drawn to the meeting, Mack heads for the Oregon wilderness and finds the dilapidated old shack. "God" miraculously transforms it into a cozy cottage, and Mack meets his supposed maker.

No, it doesn't get any stranger but sadly, it doesn't get more popular with Christians who miss the point that The Shack is intended to bring about a new definition of the Christian faith. As Albert Mohler says, "This is totally seductive and subversive, but readers, even believers, don't seem to mind." You can listen to all of his comments at this link.

If you know of someone taken in by this, please pass this commentary on to them. You'll be doing them an enormous favor. 

To learn more, visit Lighthouse Trails Research and the article The Shack: Father-goddess Rising.

I thank God for all of those who are speaking out today over outrageous issues like this one. I am reminded about the many false things promoted today written in 2 Timothy 3:16: "But evil men and seducers shall wax worse and worse, deceiving and being deceived." This is a last days' reference and if you don't think we're in them (the last days), I'll sell you a beach vacation to Minnesota in January.

RADIO: Last weekend's programming with Dr. David Reagan and Pastor Bob DeWaay provides for some captivating conversation. These are posted at "Radio Archives."  Live radio this weekend features Dr. Michael Coffman whose DVD we carry, Global Warming or Global Governance?  Kitty Foth-Regner shares her uplifting story, now in book form, Heaven Without Her.

We are live out of AM980 KKMS, Minneapolis/St. Paul, Saturdays 9 to 11 AM simulcast with AM820 KGNW, Seattle/Tacoma, 7 to 9 AM. Our other outlets, including Sirius Satellite, are tape-delayed. For podcasting, check this link. All live Saturday programming is posted to "Radio Archives" by late Monday. You can always "listen live" at www.kkms.com. They have a complete rebroadcast Sunday from 12 to 2 PM where you can also listen on line. To become a CD subscriber to our program for $30 a month getting two CDs a week, call 763-493-3010 or 763-210-8291.

Awaiting His return,
 
Jan Markell
 
You may pass on these items or have people sign up on our Web site. We update "Current Headlines" twice a day and you can access our radio programming from the last three years on "Radio Archives." Also see the Web site for other options to catch the program, "Understanding the Times."
Distributed by www.ChristianWorldviewNetwork.com

Read and post feedback

By Jan Markell

Click here for bio and archived articles

Disclaimer: Worldview Weekend, Christian Worldview Network and its columnists do not necessarily endorse or agree with every opinion expressed in every article posted on this site. We do however, encourage a healthy and friendly debate on the issues of our day. Whether you agree or disagree, we encourage you to post your feedback by using the feedback button.

3629 Views

Printer Friendly Version | E-mail this article to a friend | Return to home




Reader Feedback

It saddens me
Posted On: 06/27/08 02:42:48 PM Age 52, CA
I'm truly saddened that as Christians we have to explain a book like this as anything but heresy. It is truly anti-christ in every shape, manner and form and just a brief visit to its content quickly reveals its nature in direct oppostion to all the work accomplished by Christ on the cross. These types of discussions, critiques and reviews of a piece of fiction such as this, which by all Christians should be considered absolute garbage, are evidence of the apostasy in the church and those that call on the name of Christ. Not only is it upsetting that many cannot see the reality of this book and call themselves Christian but they actually embrace it!
Click here to reply to this post



Talk to Author
Posted On: 06/27/08 02:37:03 AM Age 53, CANADA
I think many of the misunderstandings you Jan and others have would be cleared up by speaking to the author personally and to Wayne Jacobson and others involved in this amazing publication which has been nothing short of miraculous in its own history. Before condemning a fiction book you really should understand the author's heart and his love for Jesus.
Click here to reply to this post

Crucial information
Posted On: 06/26/08 01:26:14 PM Age 66, CA
I can't hardly express my gratitude to you for this information on the "Shack". I just had a three day visit with my sister and she was immersed in this book, encouraging anyone and everyone to read it. Totally oblivious that it is meant to be 'fiction'. How many more are convinced after reading this that its the gospel truth. Satan is indeed busy and its a sure sign of our Lords return. Christians need wake up to the deception that will fall upon the earth and be grounded in His Word as a foundation for anything that comes their way. They will be equipped to recognize deception and reject it. We should all be ready to give a wise and loving answer to those who believe Satans lies. My fellow Christians brothers and sisters out there....Stay in the Word !!! Maranatha
Click here to reply to this post

  1. "Stay in the Word"
    Posted On: 06/27/08 02:27:51 AMAge 53, CANADA
    I am not sure what you mean by this because Jesus is the Word. I try to stay in relationship to him and hear his words. This seems to be what his disciples did and they had lots of questions and misunderstandings. Jesus showed them Father's Love which he wanted them to pass on because that is what is a mighty witness to Jesus to the people around us.
    Click here to reply to this post



It 's about a relationship...
Posted On: 06/26/08 09:33:03 AM Age 48, CA
By your comments on the book it makes me think you haven't read it. The reason God was a woman was because that is how the lead character would accept Him where he was at in his life. My husband who is a Pastor, and I, loved the book. We have followed Christ most of our lives. We know God walks with us everyday and without His constant love and guidance we are lost. But still at times a relationship with an invisible God is hard. This book opened that up for us. God met this man right where he was and gave him just what he needed. I've never thought before reading this book, how awesome it would be to be with Jesus in the flesh laying on a dock watching the stars with Him ....now it is something I long for someday as I now have a better understanding of what it means to have a personal relationship with our Lord and Savior. Be Blessed!
Click here to reply to this post

NOW I know WHY
Posted On: 06/26/08 09:16:08 AM Age 51, TX
Close friends kept raving over this book telling me how I just HAD to read it. I never "felt" led, wanted to, nor made the time to order it. I give the Holy Spirit thanks. Apparently He has protected me once again from such books. He did the same for me when I had NO desire to read Purposefilled Life. Everyone was pushing it down my throat, but I just could not read it... the same for The Shack. Thank you GOD for Your mighty protection. Sure, I could read these books and still maintain my walk with the Lord, but the question rises; would I open a door that cannot be closed or while open, destroy something or allow something bad in? No matter, I am glad that I have not read the book, I would rather read God's Word, and NOT out of the New International Version either.... the one that had a Lesbian on the board... the one that leaves out MAJOR scripture passages... the one that I refuse my children to memorize at their school even though it is the version of choice (I have approached leadership on this and pray that they change the version before the new school year comes!)
Click here to reply to this post



Papa?
Posted On: 06/25/08 09:34:27 PM Age 53, MN
I was utterly horrified by this book, which was given to me by someone whom I believe is truly a Christian, who was telling everyone he knew about it and had purchased 20 copies to give to people. Aside from the many obvious problems with the book, one suspicion was raised in my mind that I haven't found anyone commenting about, and I'm curious as to whether anyone knows anything about this. Young was raised in New Guinea. Isn't there an influence of Polynesian culture there? And isn't the Polynesian earth goddess called...Papa?
Click here to reply to this post

Paranoia
Posted On: 06/25/08 12:23:31 PM Age 34, KY
This site and the articles continues to make me chuckle. The book is not a dark book by any stretch. Intelligent people led by the Holy Spirit, will thoroughly enjoy this book and I'm quite sure that God will use it to glorify his Kingdom as he can do with anything. Read it, be intelligent,....and yes, be discerning but please don't be "paranoid"...lol. This article....just cracks me up! There's nothing in the book that is going to warp your mind. That takes time and I don't see one book manipulating the truth of God or our truth beliefs in Jesus Christ. It's a very tame, good natured, and fun read. Don't go all "harry potter" on this folks!!
Click here to reply to this post

  1. Your voice sounds familiar
    Posted On: 06/28/08 11:47:09 AMAge 51, GA
    Hey you sound just like that guy who said "Surely you won't die if you eat that apple". Man, if you don't understand Harry Potter and all the dangers involved, you're either checked out or never checked in.
    Click here to reply to this post

  2. Response to Mr. Paranoia
    Posted On: 06/26/08 06:42:34 AMAge 56, AR
    To Mr. Paranoia, Your remarks only confirm the scriptures in the Bible that warn of the characteristics of people in the "latter days". It also tells us of the spirit of deception that will be poured out in all nations, and that if possible, even the very "elect" would be deceived. The "elect" being the "Christians". Yes even a so called "Christian" can be deceived if they are not discerning, and know what the words of God teach us. You said, "Intelligent people led by the Holy Spirit". Not everyone fits into this category. Not even a lot of main line, so called pastors. And I really wonder about you. "Professing themselves to be wise, He made a show of them openly", or in other words He exposed their total ignorance, and stupidity. You evidently do not discern the harm this book is causing weak willed, or uneducated people,{about scriptures), who are looking for anything to help them to "feel good" about their lives. Well I have news for you. There is a Heaven, and there is a HELL! Everyone has been given a choice as to which place they want to go when they die. There will be no excuses when you stand before God. Man does not live by "bread" (food) alone. But by "EVERY" word (spirit food) that comes out of the mouth of GOD. Not just the words that man chooses to hear, or twist, to mean what he chooses for them to mean. It may help some to twist the truth of Gods words to get them through this life, and help them to "feel good" about themselves, but in the end of their lives, it will have meant absolutely nothing! You'll see.
    Click here to reply to this post



Sadly
Posted On: 06/25/08 12:18:03 PM Age 47, NC
Sadly even subscribers to ElijiahList have been bombarded with emails describing how "Wynona Judd" (yeah like SHE is an expert on God) LOVED this book and felt it brought her closer to knowing God. HEY WYNONA, WANNA KNOW GOD READ YOUR BIBLE.
Click here to reply to this post

A denominational leader mailed me this book
Posted On: 06/25/08 07:06:31 AM Age 54, WA
I pastor a church and people were asking me what I thought of The Shack. I hadn't read it but a few days later I received a copy from the overseer of our district; he had mailed each pastor a copy. Normally I don't waste time reading fiction but I decided to read it. I would never recommend this book to anyone. The Shack is one more thing that erodes the truth of who God really is. That may not be the author's intent but that's what the book does. Stay away from it and stick with that which is pure in its depiction of God. Each Sunday, pastors have the opportunity to share the truth about God with our communities. Compared to the amount of time people spend watching TV, surfing the web, and reading whatever they're reading, our time is very limited to share the truth. I pastor a wonderful group of people but I often find myself almost begging them to not only read the Bible, but to study the Bible and ask the Holy Spirit to teach them the TRUE nature and character of God. The deception that has entered the church has completely warped the true nature and character of God Himself. If Christians don't really KNOW Him, His true nature and character, they'll fall for anything. Books like this don't help.
Click here to reply to this post

  1. Who is God?
    Posted On: 06/25/08 05:33:36 PMAge 53, CANADA
    I find your comments without any substance. Have you spoken to the author? Is your theology reformed? Is all your understanding biblical? How do you reconcile love and wrath in God? Is your version of justice based on the legalistic penal substitution doctrine or grace doctrines? I find that it is easy to criticize others by picking on some minor issues which you think are unbiblical. I have been able to do this many times listening to sermons over the years. It did not help me to build my relationship with Father. Let God show himself to people as Jesus showed himself to his disciples - it took them some time to recognize that he was God in the flesh.
    Click here to reply to this post

    1. RE: who is God
      Posted On: 06/26/08 09:24:43 AMAge 39, OK
      God is not whoever/whatever we think or want him to be. The pastor to whom you replied is so right! The apostles spent 3 years with God Himself and they didnt really know Him until He came back to visit them AFTER the ressurection. They had all kinds of preconceived ideas about Him. We cant just make up or "feel" something that tells us what or who He is. His Holy Word describes Him for us. This stuff is ABSOLUTE! Who God/Jesus/Holy Spirit is is not to be debated or law vs. grace....it simply IS. There are actually a lot of absolutes in Christianity. Post modern Christians want to expand these absolutes to fit their own thoughts and feelings about God. And to anyone who says to get back into the Bible, we are intolerant or ignorant or looking only at law and no grace or gospel. It is a sad day in Christianity when people would rather get their views/beliefs of Holy God from a sinful fiction writer than from God's very own words.
      Click here to reply to this post

      1. Read the scriptures
        Posted On: 06/27/08 02:16:14 AMAge 53, CANADA
        John 3:16 says "for God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten Son" not for God so hated sin that ... His motivation in enduring the cross was not bloodlust, or even a need for punishment, but love. Jesus’ reason he was going to die was to show us his love: "Greater love has no one than this, than one lay down his life for his friends". (Jn 15:13). John 13 says " A NEW commandment I give unto you love one another as I have loved you so all men will know you are my disciples." I find these scriptures speak volumes to what the book is trying to convey about the Father. His motivation to us is firstly love because "God is love" I don't think this is who we think Jesus is it is what the scriptures declare him to be.
        Click here to reply to this post

        1. BLOODLUST?!?!!?
          Posted On: 06/27/08 04:59:55 PMAge 39, OK
          Where in the world did you get that anyone--author or those who replied--believe that God is just waiting around to zapp us? Yes, God is Love...however He is also holy and cannot abide sin. For those of us who have accepted His Son's work, we will not be judged for our sins, but the ones who have rejected will. The point of the article is that this author is making God (the Holy Trinity) human...
          Click here to reply to this post



Post Feedback

We would like to post your feedback, but please keep your feedback short and clean. All feedback will be reviewed before it is posted. We encourage healthy debating but will not accept feedback with personal attacks. Commenting on a person's public statements, actions and writings is not considered a personal attack. Please limit your feedback to less than 750 words. Comments written in ALL CAPS will not be posted.

All fields are required. Your age and state will be posted on the site, but your personal information will NOT. If you would like your name to be posted with your feedback, you must include it in your feedback text.

First Name:
Last Name:
Email Address:
City:
State: OR Country:
Age:
Feedback Title:
Your Feedback
(no HTML):
Save my information for next time.



Notice: By entering your email address, you agree to join the
Worldview Weekend email alert system.



Featured Products

10 DVD Set
Only $69.95!

Get all 10 DVDs for a low, low price!
2004 Worldview Weekend Family Reunion
Only $34.95!

Woodrow Kroll, David Jeremiah,Sean McDowell, Josh McDowell, David Barton, Carl Kerby, Frank Harber, Kerby Anderson, and the Branson Family Reunion DVD Set! This is a $74.95 value for only $34.95! FREE worksheet with purchase!
Frank Harber / Kerby Anderson
Only $14.99!

FREE worksheet with purchase!
Sean McDowell / Josh McDowell
Only $14.99!

FREE worksheet with purchase!
Woodrow Kroll / David Jeremiah
Only $14.99!

FREE worksheet with purchase!
Bob Lepine & Star Parker DVD
Only $14.99!

FREE worksheet with purchase!
Russell O'Quinn & Steve Saint DVD
Only $14.99!

FREE worksheet with purchase!
Michael Youssef & Erwin Lutzer DVD
Only $14.99!

FREE worksheet with purchase!
New Kirk Cameron & Ray Comfort DVD
Only $14.99!

FREE worksheet with purchase!
Branson 2004/2005 Music, Comedy and Variety Act DVD set
Only $19.95!

Sample Music, Comedy and Acts
2005 Worldview Weekend Family Reunion
Only $34.95!

Russell O'Quinn, Steve Saint, Dr. Michael Youssef, Dr. Erwin Lutzer, Bob Lepine, Star Parker, Kirk Cameron, Ray Comfort, and the Branson Family Reunion DVD Set! This is a $74.95 value for only $34.95!
Battle for the Mind DVD set
Only $12.00!

Site Map Christian Worldview Network - President and Founder Brannon Howse.