talk: Exposing a false dilemma Sanctity of human life Sunday January 20, 2008
There is a false dilemma at the heart of abortion talk. It goes like this: oppose abortion and you side with politics; support abortion and you side with the health and safety of women. Is it possible that the exact opposite of this is true? Perhaps those who oppose abortion side with the health and safety of women. What do thefacts substantiate?
The medical effects of abortion and post-abortion stress disorder clearly indicate that abortion is rarely a good health decision for a woman. In a congressional hearing on the impact of abortion, psychologist Wanda Franz stated, "Women who report negative after-effects from abortion know exactly what their problem is. They report horrible nightmares of children calling them from trash cans, of body parts, and blood. When they are reminded of the abortion, the women re-experienced it with terrible psychological pain ... They feel worthless and victimized because they failed at the most natural of human activities -- the role of being a mother."
Many women battle long term emotional and psychological damage because of profound regret about their abortion. Abortion proponents, who attribute these effects to induced guilt from religion and pro-life activists, trivialize the actual trauma these women endure. As a result, it is not surprising that the greatest measures of support for women facing post abortion stress disorder comes from pro-life ministries. These ministries treat seriously the feelings of women rather than trivializing them.
How long will we be duped by politically motivated deceptions? Protecting abortion is not about protecting a women’s health. Should it bother us when an organization like Planned Parenthood (while prospering on the abortion industry) intentionally deceives people about the traumatic effects of abortion? The irrefutable fact stands that abortion, as a procedure, and in its after effects, is not about the health and safety of women. It’s more about a culture of convenience, self-absorption and money.
It is frightening that a person's “being wanted or planned” is the criterion of her right to life. Yet here is another source of blatant deception. Is the life of the fetus no more than a product of conception? When a woman chooses to terminate her pregnancy is she actually terminating the life of her baby? Why do we have laws related to fetal homicide? Why do Doctor’s perform fetal surgery on a baby in the womb? Consider the following facts:
“Scientifically we are human beings by virtue of our genetic makeup. The human code in the chromosomes is there from the start. We are utterly different from monkeys or rats or elephants as soon as the chromosomes of egg and sperm meet.”
“At eight weeks, all the organs are present - brain functioning, heart pumping, liver making blood cells, kidney cleaning the fluids, fingerprints formed, etc. Yet almost all abortions happen later than this date.”
“Ultrasound has given a stunning window on the womb that shows the unborn at eight weeks sucking a thumb, recoiling from pricking, responding to sound. We can see the amazing pictures in Life Magazine or various books or Web pages.”
“There is a principle of justice that, when two legitimate rights conflict - say the woman's right not to be pregnant, and the baby's right not to be killed - the right that should be limited is the one that would do the most harm.” (Above facts from John Piper)
It’s time to enact laws that would compassionately protect both the women facing unplanned pregnancies and their babies. But until we accept the truth that induced abortion is detrimental to the physical, emotional and psychological health of women and the deliberate destruction of an unborn child, such laws will be considered extremist.
Steven W. Cornell Senior Pastor MillersvilleBibleChurch 58 West Frederick Street Millersville, PA. 17551
Disclaimer: Worldview Weekend, Christian Worldview Network and its columnists do not necessarily endorse or agree with every opinion expressed in every article posted on this site. We do however, encourage a healthy and friendly debate on the issues of our day. Whether you agree or disagree, we encourage you to post your feedback by using the feedback button.
People are always talking about the mother's "right," the "best thing for the mother," and "what if" ad nauseam. But they will NOT address the question of the personhood of the unborn! The abortion "dilemma" simply comes down to a straightforward issue: Is the unborn a person or not? If so, then he has rights, especially the bare right to exist. If not, then there is no real reason to limit a medical procedure, however repulsive. But that's all there is to it. Don't get sucked in to arguing about irrelevancies!--Mrs. Pilgrim Click here to reply to this post
Abortion
Posted On: 01/11/08 11:21:02 PM
Age 61, MO
My wife is a nurse, and for many of those years she was in the operating room, so she had a chance to speak with many doctors. She reports that it is extremely rare for a pregnancy to put a women's life in danger. Abortion therefore does virtually nothing to protect a woman's health: mental or physical. On the contrary, abortion can result in damaging a woman's physical and mental health. George Cancilla Click here to reply to this post
DEATH BRINGS DEATH
Posted On: 01/11/08 09:52:51 PM
Age 64, OH
It is very simple why politicians support women who want to murder their own baby. WOMEN CAN VOTE AND BABIES CAN NOT especially dead ones. A person says they will support the law of the land, so we should elect them for office. but the Declaration of Independence says everyone has the God given right to life. So the politicians disregards the law so as to get the votes of the women who want to kill their own babies. But mothers and fathers get old and are put in homes and now these same politicians will not protect the lives of the mothers that got old and are now in homes. You see old people who can not get to the polls are the same value to these politicians as the babied were. they did not value the life of the baby but they valued the vote. These same politicians will not value the old but they will value the vote of the children who want them dead. This cycle of death will continue until this will be a nation of death. You see, you reap whatever you sow. if you sow corn you get corn. If you sow poisonous plants you get poisonous plants. if you sow life you get life. if you sow death you get death. Lou Click here to reply to this post
