Posted: 01/07/2008 College Not Necessary for Many New Careers
by Phyllis Schlafly, January 2, 2008
U.S. News & World Report, which has made a name for itself by ranking and announcing the Best Colleges every year, is now ranking and listing the Best Careers for young people. A comparison of the latest lists shows a shocking disconnect and makes for dispiriting holiday reading.
While the price of a college education has skyrocketed far faster than inflation, many careers for which colleges prepare their graduates are disappearing. U.S. News' Best Careers guide concludes that "college grads might want to consider blue-collar careers" because B.A. diploma holders "are having trouble finding jobs that require college-graduate skills."
Incredibly, U.S. News is telling college graduates to look for jobs that do not require a college diploma. Among the 31 best opportunities for 2008 are the careers of firefighter, hairstylist, cosmetologist, locksmith, and security system technician.
Where did the higher-skill jobs go? Both large and small companies are "quietly increasing offshoring efforts."
Ten years ago we were told we really didn't need manufacturing because it can be done more cheaply elsewhere, that auto workers and others should move to Information Age jobs. But now the information jobs are moving offshore, too, as well as marketing research and even many varieties of innovation.
The flight overseas includes professional as well as low-wage jobs, with engineering jobs offshored to India and China. Thousands of bright Asian engineers are willing to work for a fraction of American wages, which is why Boeing just signed a 10-year, $1-billion-a-year deal with an Indian government-run company.
Society has been telling high school students that college is the ticket to get a life, and politicians are pandering to parents' desire for their children to be better educated and so have a higher standard of living. John Edwards wants the taxpayers to guarantee every kid a college education, and Mitt Romney says more education is the means for Americans to compete in a global economy.
But it doesn't make sense for parents to mortgage their homes, or for students to saddle themselves with long-term debt, in order to pay overpriced college tuition to prepare for jobs that no longer exist. Tuition at public universities has risen an unprecedented 51 percent over the past five years.
President Bush calls the loss of U.S. jobs "the pinch some of you folks are feeling." I guess his words are designed to show his "compassionate conservatism," but the reality is far more than a pinch.
U.S. News offers this advice for the nerds who still spend five to six years earning an engineering degree despite increasingly grim prospects of a well-paid engineering career: "Look for government work." Or maybe you can be an "Offshoring Manager" and be part of the process of shipping your fellow graduates' jobs overseas.
A Duke University spokesman said that 40 percent of Duke's engineering graduates cannot get engineering jobs. A Duke University publication suggests that the best prospect for good engineering jobs is for the U.S. government to start another major project like going to the moon.
U.S. News warns us that "government is becoming an employer of choice." Corporations are getting leaner, but government can continue to pay good salaries, with lots of vacation days, sick leave, health insurance and retirement benefits, because government rakes in more tax revenue in good times and can raise taxes in bad times; and if the Democrats win in 2008, we can expect government to expand even more.
Presidential candidates have gotten the message from grassroots Americans that we want our borders closed to illegal aliens. Headlines now proclaim "Immigration Moves to Front and Center of G.O.P. Race" and "G.O.P. Candidates Hold Fast on Immigration at Debate."
But G.O.P. candidates haven't yet gotten the message that jobs are just as big a gut issue as immigration. The Wall Street Journal/NBC News survey conducted December 14-17 reports that, by 58 to 28 percent, Americans believe globalization is bad because it subjects U.S. companies and employees to unfair competition and cheap labor.
Where are the limited-government fiscal-conservatives when we need them to refute the notion that the best an engineering graduate can hope for is a job with the government? Are the fiscal-conservatives too busy chanting the failed mantra of "free trade" even though it has resulted in millions of good American jobs being shipped overseas?
When are we going to call a halt to the way globalism is destroying U.S. jobs by foreign currency manipulation, theft of our intellectual property, shipping us poisonous seafood and toys, and unfair trade agreements that allow foreign subsidies (through the so-called Value Added Tax) to massively discriminate against U.S. producers and workers?
Disclaimer: Worldview Weekend, Christian Worldview Network and its columnists do not necessarily endorse or agree with every opinion expressed in every article posted on this site. We do however, encourage a healthy and friendly debate on the issues of our day. Whether you agree or disagree, we encourage you to post your feedback by using the feedback button.
Not all government jobs pay a lot. Unless you a Senator or President. If you are a policemen, social worker, state, county and city employee, etc you do not make much at all. Click here to reply to this post
College is more necessary than some believe
Posted On: 01/10/08 01:30:15 PM
Age 43, TX
Some of our young adults have bought into “we don’t need a college degree”. That would be nice not to have to pay the ever increasing cost of college, but it’s simply not true for those who want make a better living. If you have a skill or craft you might be able to do without a college degree to get a higher paying job. And even then, some businesses want you to have some kind of school or training for those. I wish colleges were not allowed to charge so much. They charge for all kinds of services that some people never need. The book prices are outrageous and are updated every two or three years so it’s harder to resell. Where does all that money go? They don’t pay the professors or other employees very much. Click here to reply to this post
hate to tell you this phyllis,
Posted On: 01/09/08 11:16:46 AM
Age 23, PW
But engineering degrees are usually four year programs. And we have just as many "nerds" as any other major... hate to rain on your stereotype parade.
You talk about "unfair competition". What on earth is unfair competition? You mean you don't LIKE overseas competition? Too bad. Welcome to the 21st century.
And why do you think that the fed. gov't will expand under Democrats only? Huckabee, Romney, Giuliani, McCain... all of these neo-cons are just like Bush: tax and spend, tax and spend. Stop dreaming. Vote Ron Paul. Click here to reply to this post
I got my degree w/ zero debt through accelerated distance learning from a company called CollegePlus! You can check out their website at www.collegeplus.org. My degree cost under $8k and is regionally accredited. This is the answer to the education dilemma! Click here to reply to this post
College not necessary
Posted On: 01/07/08 01:26:19 PM
Age 61, MO
I believe Congressman Ron Paul is the limited government fiscal conservative you are looking for. But more like minded representatives will be needed in the Federal legislature and in all levels of government. The "free trade" of a NAFTA is NOT free, but rather politically manipulated trade which favors only a few multinational corporations. Jobs suitable for college graduates are not available, in large part, because of NAFTA outsourcing; yet colleges, who know this, continue to solicit students, usually causing students to have huge debt loads when they graduate. Capitalism was never meant to be a completely free system of economic interaction. Early ideas for capitalism in the U.S. came from Adam Smith’s “Wealth of Nations.” Smith identified several items that would have to be in place for his capitalism to work effectively: 1) There would be no separation of ownership and management. 2) There would be certain social costs that no one private individual would want to provide; thus giving these costs over to the governing bodies. 3) Any capitalistic economic system would have to be confined to sovereign national boundaries. (The basis and the ability of the market place to determine supply and demand and price, rests in the ability of individuals to move easily from one industry to another to provide goods and services. This is obviously not possible across national boundaries). The U.S. governments, both Federal and State, must firmly establish economic rules that encompass the three tenets stated above. Appropriate tariffs and monopoly busting legislation are probably necessary. Global capital flight through private banks and the stock market must be prohibited and/or highly regulated. Of course, making necessary changes requires citizens to be honest with themselves and to elect honest representatives. George Cancilla Click here to reply to this post
Woodrow Kroll, David Jeremiah,Sean McDowell, Josh McDowell, David Barton, Carl Kerby, Frank Harber, Kerby Anderson, and the Branson Family Reunion DVD Set! This is a $74.95 value for only $34.95! FREE worksheet with purchase!
Russell O'Quinn, Steve Saint, Dr. Michael Youssef, Dr. Erwin Lutzer, Bob Lepine, Star Parker, Kirk Cameron, Ray Comfort, and the Branson Family Reunion DVD Set! This is a $74.95 value for only $34.95!