Radio Programs - Now Playing
Crosstalk

Listen to Archives, Read/Leave Feedback
Today's Schedule, Radio Show List
The Uniqueness of Jesus Christ in a World of Religions
by Brannon Howse
Upcoming Conferences
November 22, 2008
Wichita, Kansas

November 23, 2008
Kansas City, Kansas

April 24, 25 & 26, 2009
Branson, Missouri

Meet Brannon Howse
President & Founder, View Bio

Brannon Howse

Schedule Brannon
for your next event
Search
Search:

View articles by:



Summit Ministries























Worldview DVDs
Bob Cornuke and David Limbaugh DVD
Only $14.99!

Brannon Howse / Voddie Baucham Jr. DVD
Only $14.99!

Candace Cameron/Brannon Howse DVD
Only $15.00!

David Barton / Carl Kerby DVD
Only $14.99!
David Barton and David Jeremiah DVD
Only $14.99!

David Barton DVD
Only $9.99!
Dr. Marshall Foster / Janet Folger
Only $14.99!
Jason Carlson/Mark Cahill DVD
Only $15.00!

Ken Ham DVD
Only $14.99!

Kerby Anderson / Dr. Marshall Foster
Only $14.99!
Michael Reagan DVD
Only $14.99!

Norm Geisler / Norm Geisler
Only $14.99!
Ravi Zacharias and Brannon Howse DVD
Only $14.99!

Ron Carlson / Brannon Howse
Only $14.99!
Sean McDowell / Josh McDowell DVD
Only $14.99!

Woodrow Kroll / David Jeremiah DVD
Only $14.99!

Bad New Plans to Rewrite the Constitution



Posted: 11/19/2007
Bad New Plans to Rewrite the Constitution


by Phyllis Schlafly, November 21, 2007

Let's face it. Some people, especially liberals, just don't like our United States Constitution. Every few years, they come up with wild or devious plans to make major changes.

The would-be rewriters of the Constitution do not merely propose amendments to remedy a problem, as allowed for in Article V. They seek structural change after hurling put-downs such as archaic, out-of-date, and dating from the horse-and-buggy era.

The latest to imagine that he can write a 21st century improvement on our great Constitution is University of Virginia professor Larry J. Sabato, whom the Washington Post once dubbed "the Mark McGwire of political analysts." His rhetoric may be on steroids but his ideas for a "more perfect" Constitution sound like warmed-over Rhodes-scholar dissatisfaction with impudent American revolutionaries who dared to reject the British system and write an original document.

Here are some of Sabato's 23 Proposals to Revitalize Our Constitution, which he set forth in his new book entitled "A More Perfect Constitution."

  • Sabato wants to make all former Presidents and Vice Presidents "National Senators." I guess the prospect of Bill Clinton as First Gentleman in the White House isn't a sure thing, so we should meanwhile guarantee him a speaking platform in the Senate.

  • Sabato would erase the great compromise of our Constitution which produced a federal union: the bicameral Congress with the House based on population and the Senate based on state representation. He wants to give the 10 most populous states two additional Senators, the 15 next most populous states one additional Senator, and the District of Columbia one Senator.

  • Of course, Sabato doesn't like our Electoral College. The liberals have been carping about the Electoral College system for years, and when Hillary Clinton celebrated her victory as Senator from New York, her first pronouncement was that we have "outlived the need for an Electoral College" and it should be abolished.

    Sabato wants to manipulate the Electoral College in a way he claims will reduce the chances that a president will win without a majority of the popular vote. Because of third parties, we've had many elections (including three of the last four), when no presidential candidate received a popular-vote majority.

    Sabato can't prevent this unless he bans third parties. We are fortunate that we now have a proven system that allows our President to achieve an Electoral College majority that validates his election.

  • Sabato would abolish the constitutional provision that the President and Vice President shall be "a natural born citizen." That will bring cheers from the open-borders crowd eager to build a majority of diverse people unfamiliar with our American rule of law.

  • Sabato wants to elect our President and all Senate and House members at the same time. He would accomplish this by changing House terms from two to three years, and setting Senate terms to coincide with presidential elections.

    But our Constitution was not designed for efficiency of process in either elections or legislation. It was designed to limit the power of government in order to preserve liberty.

  • Sabato calls for giving federal judges guaranteed cost-of-living pay increases. That's one more way to reinforce special privilege for elitist judges.

  • Sabato wants to write a new procedure for a four-month presidential primary system into the Constitution. Whatever problems we have with primaries cannot be remedied by imposing the rigidity of a constitutionally mandated calendar.

  • Sabato wants to allow the House of Representatives to be appointed (rather than elected) in the event of extensive deaths or incapacitation. It's a very undemocratic idea ever to abandon the requirement that all House Members must be elected by the people.

  • Sabato's proposals are a potpourri of so many bad liberal ideas. His proposed constitution would require two years of mandatory national (military) service for all young men and women, and taxpayer financing for congressional campaigns.

  • Who knows what mischief is lurking under the Sabato's proposal that his new constitution would require an automatic registration system for U.S. citizens in order to guarantee that their right to vote is not "abridged by bureaucratic requirements"? Is this an underhanded way to help the liberals invalidate state requirements that voters show a valid ID?

  • The worst of all Sabato's proposals is to call for a new Constitutional Convention that would scrap our present Constitution and start over from a clean slate. We don't see any James Madisons, George Washingtons or Ben Franklins around today, and we're mighty worried about the men who think they are capable of rewriting our Constitution.

When Sabato recently gathered a few people to discuss his proposals, Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito summed up the reaction not only of those at the meeting, but of the rest of us, too. "I'm pretty fond of the Constitution we have now," he said. Thank you, Justice Alito. So are we.

Distributed by www.ChristianWorldviewNetwork.com

Read and post feedback

By Phyllis Schlafly

Click here for bio and archived articles

Disclaimer: Worldview Weekend, Christian Worldview Network and its columnists do not necessarily endorse or agree with every opinion expressed in every article posted on this site. We do however, encourage a healthy and friendly debate on the issues of our day. Whether you agree or disagree, we encourage you to post your feedback by using the feedback button.

1320 Views

Printer Friendly Version | E-mail this article to a friend | Return to home




Reader Feedback

Re: Bad New Plans to Rewrite the Constitution
Posted On: 11/22/07 06:39:19 PM Age 42, FL
Sabato's plans to rewrite the constitution are bad and need to be rejected. If anything good can come from these ideas, it will be to inspire Americans to examine our Constitution and recommit ourselves to these ideals of liberty, free enterprise. That's why I support Ron Paul in January's Primary.
Click here to reply to this post



Re: Bad New Plans to Rewrite the Constitution
Posted On: 11/20/07 07:06:43 PM Age 30, WI
sorry, i don't understand why these ideas are all bad or necessarily "liberal." from what i understand, the constitution allows for changes and amendments and that many have been proposed throughout our nation's history. that is part of the democratic process. some of the suggestions--particularly the one that everyone must serve in the military or civil service--sound like ideas worth considering. is there anything theologically wrong with these suggestions? anything inconsistent with biblical teaching?
Click here to reply to this post

  1. Re: Re: Bad New Plans to Rewrite the Constitution
    Posted On: 11/26/07 10:20:11 AMAge 64, OH
    There is no provision in the US Constitution to scrap it and rewrite it. Sabato's plan is NOT Biblical or Constitutional. Did you read the article. Lou
    Click here to reply to this post

Re: Bad New Plans to Rewrite the Constitution
Posted On: 11/20/07 06:29:17 PM Age 39, KS
It is a very bad idea to have a rewrite or even a constitutional amending happen, because it would open doors for such things as this to happen and overthrow biblical concerns for writing in amendments, such as on life and marriage. (Reminds me of the amendments that were to take place with the Articles of Confederation, instead you had a secret closed door meeting, and we then ended up with the constitution.) There are already provisions in the Constitution for such matters, but we as a people have chosen to ignore the Constitution. We are in an illegal war, yet many of my fellow conservatives won't support the most constitutionally minded candidate for president because he is against the illegal war, undeclared war in Iraq, the unconstitutional war on drugs (at the federal level), etc.... People who truly care about the U.S. Constitution should all be supporting Ron Paul as he is the only candidate that has a clue what it means and plans to abide by it. He truly means what he says when he takes his oath of office to uphold the Constitution. He isn't off on a Christian platform, even though he does hold biblical values dear to his heart (read more about this at http://www.lewrockwell.com/vance/vance127.html ) Rewrite or amending is BAD NEWS! wwww.ronpaul2008.com
Click here to reply to this post



Re: Bad New Plans to Rewrite the Constitution
Posted On: 11/20/07 10:32:26 AM Age 86, NC
Sorry Larry -- You have bee 'one-upped' by the Queen of American Politics and Logic, America's own Maggie Thatcher. Go about your regular business with the knowledge that you have been one-upped by the best....
Click here to reply to this post

BLOOD OR PROFIT
Posted On: 11/20/07 09:32:42 AM Age 64, OH
These men who want to rewrite the constitution have not shed any of their blood to show that they are worthy to do so. The writers of our present constitution proved their qualifications by their sacrifice of blood and treasure. The men that want to rewrite our beloved document have instead of sacrifice made themselves rich off of the people who they claim to want to protect. They have already had their chance to protect the people and instead they reaped the fat of the land and left the people poor. If you are low on blood you don't need leaches but you need donors. Lou
Click here to reply to this post

  1. Re: BLOOD OR PROFIT
    Posted On: 11/25/07 08:20:53 PMAge 61, MO
    "If you are low on blood you don't need leaches but you need donors." I like that line Lou. It reminds me of the line in the movie "Bees" at the end where the main bee has the mosquito on his law team, and his client says, "I didn't know you were a lawyer too." And the mosquito replies: "It wasn't hard to become a lawyer. I was already a blood sucking parasite. All I needed was a briefcase." What good would it do to rewrite the constitution? Most elected officials don't abide by the one we have already. George Cancilla
    Click here to reply to this post

    1. Re: Re: BLOOD OR PROFIT
      Posted On: 11/28/07 04:40:36 PMAge 64, OH
      George you are more of a man than most that I have run across. It was generous of you to pay me any compliment at all. For I have been critical of your views sometimes, although sometimes I have wrote in agreement with you. I encourage you in the Lord Jesus who is everything. Any man who has Christ has everything there is to possess and lacks not one thing, Paul said. I hope to see you on the other side of the Jordon. Lou
      Click here to reply to this post



Re: Bad New Plans to Rewrite the Constitution
Posted On: 11/20/07 06:11:21 AM Age 47, MO
While I agree that rewriting the Constitution is a bad idea, it is certainly better than ignoring the Constitution. We are in an illegal war, yet many of my fellow conservatives won't support the most constitutionally minded candidate for president because he is against the illegal war, undeclared war in Iraq, the unconstitutional war on drugs (at the federal level), etc.... People who truly care about the U.S. Constitution should all be supporting Ron Paul as he is the only candidate that has a clue what it means and plans to abide by it. He truly means what he says when he takes his oath of office to uphold the Constitution. http://www.ronpaul2008.com
Click here to reply to this post



Post Feedback

We would like to post your feedback, but please keep your feedback short and clean. All feedback will be reviewed before it is posted. We encourage healthy debating but will not accept feedback with personal attacks. Commenting on a person's public statements, actions and writings is not considered a personal attack. Please limit your feedback to less than 750 words. Comments written in ALL CAPS will not be posted.

All fields are required. Your age and state will be posted on the site, but your personal information will NOT. If you would like your name to be posted with your feedback, you must include it in your feedback text.

First Name:
Last Name:
Email Address:
City:
State: OR Country:
Age:
Feedback Title:
Your Feedback
(no HTML):
Save my information for next time.



Notice: By entering your email address, you agree to join the
Worldview Weekend email alert system.



Featured Products

10 DVD Set
Only $69.95!

Get all 10 DVDs for a low, low price!
2004 Worldview Weekend Family Reunion
Only $34.95!

Woodrow Kroll, David Jeremiah,Sean McDowell, Josh McDowell, David Barton, Carl Kerby, Frank Harber, Kerby Anderson, and the Branson Family Reunion DVD Set! This is a $74.95 value for only $34.95! FREE worksheet with purchase!
Frank Harber / Kerby Anderson
Only $14.99!

FREE worksheet with purchase!
Sean McDowell / Josh McDowell
Only $14.99!

FREE worksheet with purchase!
Woodrow Kroll / David Jeremiah
Only $14.99!

FREE worksheet with purchase!
Bob Lepine & Star Parker DVD
Only $14.99!

FREE worksheet with purchase!
Russell O'Quinn & Steve Saint DVD
Only $14.99!

FREE worksheet with purchase!
Michael Youssef & Erwin Lutzer DVD
Only $14.99!

FREE worksheet with purchase!
New Kirk Cameron & Ray Comfort DVD
Only $14.99!

FREE worksheet with purchase!
Branson 2004/2005 Music, Comedy and Variety Act DVD set
Only $19.95!

Sample Music, Comedy and Acts
2005 Worldview Weekend Family Reunion
Only $34.95!

Russell O'Quinn, Steve Saint, Dr. Michael Youssef, Dr. Erwin Lutzer, Bob Lepine, Star Parker, Kirk Cameron, Ray Comfort, and the Branson Family Reunion DVD Set! This is a $74.95 value for only $34.95!
Battle for the Mind DVD set
Only $12.00!

Site Map Christian Worldview Network - President and Founder Brannon Howse.